The Critics' Take on Matthew Broderick's Tartuffe: A Delight or Disappointment?
The New York Theatre Workshop's revival of Tartuffe, starring the renowned actor Matthew Broderick, has opened to a mix of critical reception. The play, adapted from Molière's classic by A Doll's House, Part 2 playwright Lucas Hnath, is set to run until January 24, 2026, with an already extended limited engagement. This production boasts a stellar cast, including David Cross, Bianca Del Rio, Amber Gray, Ryan J. Haddad, Francis Jue, and more.
Broderick takes on the title role, with a supporting cast that includes Emmy Award winner David Cross, Obie Award winner Emily Davis, RuPaul's Drag Race winner Bianca Del Rio, Tony nominee Amber Gray, Obie winner Ryan J. Haddad, 2025 Tony winner Francis Jue, Tony winner Lisa Kron, and Emmy nominee Ikechukwu Ufomadu. The creative team behind the revival is equally impressive, featuring choreographer Raja Feather Kelly, composer Heather Christian, scenic designer dots, costume designer Enver Chakartash, lighting designer Stacey Derosier, and sound designer Peter Mills Weiss. Kasson Marroquin serves as the production stage manager.
While some critics were charmed by Broderick's performance and the overall production, others found it lacking. The play's exploration of themes such as deception and moral ambiguity may have divided opinions, with some reviewers praising its wit and humor, while others found it too subtle or not engaging enough. The production's unique take on a classic text has sparked discussions, with some praising its modern adaptation and others criticizing its departure from the original.
The reviews are in, and the verdict is mixed. Will you be captivated by Tartuffe? Read the reviews and decide for yourself.
*Note: Access to the full reviews may require creating a free account or a paid subscription. Playbill will continue to update this list as more reviews come in.
